Thinking Trades - Premium Service

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Education

Entertainment

Value

Reviewed June 2013

World's greatest crook & liar

This guy is an absolute LIar. On his blog, he has posted $4500 as gain for the month of April where as he has lost 12K in one month in one of the accts and 6K in a another. I paid him to trade for me 45 days ago. Do not trust a word he says. If you want proof I can provide statements. I can't understand how people like him are allowed to be in this business & cheat people.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

1 of 1 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

Review Updated

Liar, Liar Liar

Vinay is an absolute LIar. On his blog, he has posted $4500 as gain for the month of April where as he has lost 20K in one month in my account. I paid him to trade for me 45 days ago. Do not trust a word he says. If you want proof I can provide statements. I can't understand how people like him are allowed to be in this business & cheat people.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials.com member and not of Investimonials LLC.

Jasmine

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Education

Reviewed May 2013

The best of the best

Have been following him on twitter and stock twits and this guy has been so right that at times I am left wondering if he has any inside knowledge. I recently joined the premium service and already up significantly in a few months. This is one service that I would give full marks for performance and transparency. I whole heartedly recommend this service.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

2 of 4 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

1 Comment on this Review

BillyBob

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Value

Reviewed February 2013

This guy is killing it

Amazing performance. What more can I say when everything is as clear as it can be? I have tried more than 10 services but no one comes even close to this service as far as consistency or transparency is concerned.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

3 of 5 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

Bookingprofits

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Education

Value

Reviewed January 2013

Makes money for subs

This service makes money for subs. I am a subscriber to Stocks and Level 1 options. This service has evolved with time. Making money was never an issue but Vinay was giving back a portion of profits during corrections. Not any more. In the last year or so, this service has made money even during corrections rather than losing it. Making money with very little volatility has been a hallmark of this service in the past year. It's an easy recommendation based on my experience and long enough track record.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

3 of 5 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

TradingAddict

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Education

Entertainment

Value

Reviewed January 2013

Super duper service

Why can't every trading service publish the track record. It's a great way to advertise one's service but still the majority doesn't publish results. There is no need for reviews if one can see the performance. Have been with this service for long enough and it's a gold mine. I whole heartedly recommend it.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

6 of 8 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

1nvestwise

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Education

Value

Reviewed January 2013

Won't find a better run stock trading service

A brilliant service that takes the burden out of trading. In a way I have outsourced the burden of watching and making sense of the market to thinkingtrades for a very very reasonable fee. Outstanding results in this messy market. I couldn't have asked for more. Unbelievably smooth ride so far. Touchwood!

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

7 of 9 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

Trader1972

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Value

Reviewed January 2013

Delivers in spades

This is a no frills service but it delivers in spades. I am a subscriber to the stocks service. The service takes a portfolio approach so it is easy to allocate capital and not worry about missing any trades. He is transparent and keeps track of all his trades. The performance has been outstanding so far. I am not the one to follow someone blindly but over time I have become very comfortable trading the picks. He does have a good understanding of the market.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

5 of 7 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

Emerald

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Value

Reviewed December 2012

Love it

Have not been a subscriber to Futures but have been a subscriber to the stock service for 7 months and recently subscribed to Level 2 options. Simple and straight forward service. One receives email alerts when it's time to execute a trade. The performance track record is awesome. It works pretty well with my full time job. I have so much faith by now that I just execute the trade on my iPhone as soon as I receive the alert.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

4 of 5 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

Optionstrader66

User’s Review Ratings

Overall

Value

Reviewed December 2012

Very pleased

Easy to follow. Very clear and precise alerts. Worth every penny. Have tried many services before where good stretches last much less than bad. This one is different, every bad stretch is followed by a much longer good stretch. Eventually one's equity curve goes up. And it's no secret, as can be seen by the performance statistics. This service pays off many many times over. The only thing one needs is patience when there is a rough patch else one will easily get shaken out. I can say that from experience since I left and came back again when I realized what I missed by leaving.

This review is the subjective opinion of an Investimonials member and not of Investimonials LLC

6 of 7 people have found this review helpful.

Embed | Permalink | Report

Was this review helpful? Yes No

5 Comments on this Review

kimk

Sara, did you trade with him in July-August when he lost 60% of the account in two weeks?

brad

Ha ha moron kimk is back. Lost money, my foot. This moron doesn't even want to give back money from profits. I am ahead by a mile from my starting capital base. We are playing with free money moron now. Yeah you can't even put 2 and 2 together and see that the portfolio is already up by more than 100%. Get a real job moron but then who will give you moron a job. Oh yeah you have a full time job here of reviewing services.

sara

ok guys let's keep it civil. Yes, I was trading when he lost money back then. I was comfortably ahead in my account until then so had to give back a chunk of profits back but it came back again as soon as it went away. Everyone will have a different experience based on what time one joined the service. The equity curve is not smooth and it never can be. The point is over a period of time it all should work out. I also subscribe to options. I was pretty much flat after first 6 months of this year and then made more than 30k until now. That too in the most difficult period. I am sure many would get frustrated by then and would quit. In hindsight, it would not look such a good decision.

kimk

Yes, I guess it makes huge difference when you join. This is true for any service. I joined the service in January and followed him on paper for few months (I never put real money into any service till I have full confidence). On March 1st he ignored his own stops and lost 3.5k in one day. He said it will never happen again, but I felt I just cannot trust him anymore.

Any service will have drawdowns, the question is how big they are. 60% in two weeks is definitely not acceptable by any standards. Risk management is the most important thing in trading, and in this case, risk management is non-existent. The concept of playing with “free money” is very dangerous. Once the profit is earned, it’s your money. Every day is a new day.

My question to you is the same: if the alerts are based on 25k portfolio, how could he start trading NQ and TF in August while having two ES contracts losing ~15k at this point? Wouldn’t you get a margin call? And if you are using bigger account to trade 4 contracts (which you should), then your percentage gains are very far from advertised ones, especially considering slippage, commissions and subscription fees.

sara

As I said I have already profits from the service so my portfolio is larger than 25k. Vinay might argue that the portfolio value is more than double from 25k starting figure. My belief is that everyone has to decide for themselves as far as how much they want to risk. It's just an alert service and at the end of the day I have the control on money that I am trading with. Some may be trading the service with 25k and some with much larger account and some may be trading with less than 25k. I do not even worry about the percentage gain because it's debatable. You say that if one has to trade with more than 25k than its' less than what he is showing. He can say that it's based on 25k where as he generally trades only 1 or 2 contracts. He is not using the whole 25k generally.

I have tried a few other futures services. The slippage is not that bad compared to some of the other services. Some slippage is unavoidable. After slippage and commissions, I am able to make about 75-80% of what is shown.

As I said the sum total experience has been fine for me. He tracks the trades correctly. This is one thing that was missing from most other services that I subscribed to before. There was no benchmark to compare at the end of the day.

Leave a Comment

Sara